South Jersey vs Philadelphia: Why More People Are Moving Across the River

Every year, thousands of buyers cross the Delaware River from Philadelphia into South Jersey. They are leaving the city's rowhomes, rising property taxes, and competitive school landscape for more space, better schools, and a lower cost of living. But the decision is not as simple as it sounds. Each side has real trade-offs, and the right choice depends on what matters most to you.

I have worked with dozens of buyers who made this exact decision. Some chose South Jersey and never looked back. Others found that the city was the better fit. This guide lays out the facts side by side so you can make the choice that is right for your family.

How Does Housing Cost Compare?

Housing is typically the biggest factor in the decision, and the numbers tell a revealing story:

Philadelphia. The median home price in Philadelphia is approximately $235,000 as of mid-2024, but this varies dramatically by neighborhood. In desirable areas like Fairmount, Graduate Hospital, or Queen Village, median prices range from $400,000 to $600,000 or more. Fishtown and Kensington, which have seen significant appreciation, now average $300,000 to $500,000. A 1,200-square-foot rowhome in a good neighborhood will typically cost $400,000 to $500,000.

South Jersey (Burlington County). The median home price in Burlington County is approximately $350,000 to $485,000, depending on the town. However, that price buys substantially more space. A $450,000 budget in Moorestown or Mount Laurel typically gets you a 2,000+ square-foot single-family home on a quarter-acre lot with a backyard, a garage, and top-rated schools. In towns like Lumberton or Cinnaminson, the same budget goes even further.

The bottom line: You get roughly 60-80% more square footage and a much larger lot in South Jersey for a similar or slightly higher purchase price. The trade-off is higher property taxes (discussed below).

How Do Property Taxes Compare?

This is the single biggest financial difference between the two sides of the river:

• Philadelphia: The City of Philadelphia's property tax rate is approximately 1.4% of assessed value. However, the city's Actual Value Initiative (AVI) means assessments are closer to market value than in many jurisdictions. The average annual tax bill in Philadelphia is roughly $3,000 to $5,000 for a typical home.
• South Jersey: New Jersey has the highest property taxes in the country. Burlington County effective rates range from 2.4% to 2.8% of assessed value. The average annual tax bill in Moorestown is approximately $12,000 to $16,000. In Medford, $8,000 to $12,000. In Mount Laurel, $7,000 to $10,000.

On the surface, this makes South Jersey look significantly more expensive. But the full picture is more nuanced. Higher taxes fund the excellent public schools, municipal services, and infrastructure that residents depend on. When you factor in the cost of private school tuition in Philadelphia (which can run $15,000 to $40,000 per year per child), the comparison becomes more favorable for South Jersey families.

How Do Schools Compare?

For families with children, this is often the deciding factor:

• Philadelphia: The School District of Philadelphia has faced significant challenges, including underfunding, aging facilities, and inconsistent outcomes. While there are excellent magnet and charter schools, admission is competitive, and the quality of neighborhood schools varies widely. Many families who can afford it choose private school, adding $15,000 to $40,000 per year in tuition costs.
• South Jersey: Suburban school districts in Burlington County consistently rank among the best in New Jersey and the nation. Moorestown is ranked #10 in New Jersey by Niche. Haddonfield, Mount Laurel, Medford, and Marlton all have highly rated schools. Public schools are the standard, and most families are satisfied with the quality of education.

For families who plan to have children or who already have school-age kids, the school quality gap is often the single most compelling reason to choose South Jersey. The cost of private school in Philadelphia can easily offset the property tax difference.

What About the Commute?

If you work in Philadelphia, the commute from South Jersey is surprisingly manageable:

• From Burlington County towns to Center City: 20-40 minutes by car, depending on the town. The Tacony-Palmyra Bridge, Ben Franklin Bridge, and Walt Whitman Bridge all provide direct access.
• PATCO Speedline: From Cherry Hill, Haddonfield, or Collingswood, PATCO reaches Center City in 15-25 minutes. Trains run frequently, and Park-and-Ride lots are available at most stations.
• NJ Transit: Bus routes from Burlington County towns and the River LINE light rail provide additional public transit options.
• Reverse commute: If you live in Philadelphia and work in South Jersey, the reverse commute is also manageable, with easy access to the same bridges and highways.

Living in Philadelphia obviously means a shorter commute if you work in the city. But for many South Jersey residents, the 20-to-40-minute drive is a trade-off they willingly make for the space, schools, and quality of life they gain.

How Does Lifestyle Compare?

Lifestyle is harder to quantify but equally important:

• Philadelphia offers walkability, world-class dining, museums, nightlife, professional sports, and a dense urban experience. If you want to walk to restaurants, bars, and cultural venues, the city is hard to beat. The trade-off is less space, parking challenges, and the urban challenges that come with any major city.
• South Jersey offers a quieter, more suburban lifestyle. You trade walkability for space, privacy, and a yard. Most towns have a downtown area with local shops and restaurants, but you will drive to most destinations. The cultural and dining scene of Philadelphia remains accessible, just a 20-to-40-minute drive away.

The best choice depends on the lifestyle you want day to day. If you eat out four nights a week and walk to work, the city may be the better fit. If you want a backyard, a garden, and a neighborhood where kids play in the street, South Jersey is hard to beat.

What Are the Hidden Costs of Each Side?

Beyond the obvious price tags, there are costs that buyers often overlook:

Philadelphia hidden costs:

• City wage tax (3.75% for residents, 3.44% for non-residents who work in the city)
• Private school tuition if you are not satisfied with public school options
• Parking costs (garage parking can run $200-$400 per month)
• Higher car insurance rates in the city

South Jersey hidden costs:

• Higher property taxes (the biggest factor)
• Car dependency (you will need at least one vehicle per household)
• Commuting costs (gas, tolls, maintenance if you drive to the city)
• Higher utility costs in larger homes, especially for heating and cooling

Which Side Wins for Different Buyer Types?

Here is a quick guide to which side tends to be the better fit for different situations:

• First-time buyers with a $250K-$350K budget: South Jersey offers better value. Entry-level homes in Mount Laurel, Lumberton, Cinnaminson, or Maple Shade give you a single-family home with a yard. In Philadelphia, the same budget buys a smaller rowhome or a condo in a less central neighborhood.
• Growing families: South Jersey, by a wide margin. The schools, space, and safety are unmatched for families with children.
• Young professionals without children: Philadelphia, if you value walkability, nightlife, and a short commute. South Jersey, if you value space and a quieter lifestyle.
• Empty nesters and downsizers: It depends. Some prefer the walkability of the city. Others prefer the space and lower-maintenance living in a South Jersey townhome or condo community.
• Investors: Both markets have strong rental demand. Philadelphia offers higher density and short-term rental potential. South Jersey offers stable long-term tenants and lower acquisition costs relative to rental income.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Side Should You Choose?

There is no universal right answer. The best choice depends on your priorities, your budget, and the lifestyle you want. But here is what I tell every buyer I work with:

If you value space, schools, safety, and a yard, South Jersey is the better choice. The commute is manageable, the value is strong, and you can still access everything Philadelphia offers on weekends.

If you value walkability, urban energy, and a short commute above all else, Philadelphia may be the better fit. Just be honest about what you are giving up in space, school quality, and overall cost.

I have helped dozens of families on both sides of the river make this decision. If you are trying to decide, I would be happy to talk through your specific situation. No pressure, just honest guidance.

Contact Bob Schedule a Call