Medford is better for buyers who value historic character, larger properties, and access to outdoor recreation, while Marlton is better for buyers who want convenience, abundant shopping and dining, a shorter commute to Philadelphia, and more affordable entry-level housing. The right pick depends on which lifestyle fits your priorities.
I have helped dozens of families buy and sell homes in both towns over the past 20 years. Here is my honest, side-by-side comparison of Medford and Marlton to help you decide which community fits your lifestyle and budget.
For a deeper look at each town, visit the Medford Community Guide and Marlton Community Guide.
Which Town Has a Lower Cost of Living?
Both towns are in a similar price range, but the differences matter depending on what you are looking for.
Medford: The median home price in Medford ranges from $450,000 to $650,000, with an entry point in the mid-$400,000s. Property taxes average $8,000 to $11,500 annually. The higher floor reflects the larger lots and more distinctive housing stock. You get more land and character, but you pay for it.
Marlton: The median home price in Marlton ranges from $425,000 to $600,000, with an entry point in the mid-$300,000s for townhomes and smaller homes. Property taxes average $7,500 to $10,000 annually. Marlton is generally more affordable for comparable square footage, though you get a smaller lot.
Winner: Marlton, for overall affordability. Medford offers more land and character for the higher price. For a detailed breakdown of Medford's costs, read our Cost of Living in Medford guide.
Which Town Has Better Schools?
Both towns have excellent school systems, but they are structured differently.
Medford: Medford Township Public Schools serve elementary and middle school students, with all students attending Shawnee High School through the Lenape Regional High School District. Shawnee is consistently ranked among the top high schools in New Jersey. The elementary schools are highly regarded, and the small district feel is a draw for many families.
Marlton: Marlton is served by the Evesham Township School District, with students attending Cherokee High School through the Lenape Regional District. Cherokee is also a top-ranked high school with strong academics, arts, and athletics. The elementary schools in Marlton are excellent.
Winner: Tie. Both Shawnee and Cherokee are outstanding high schools. The choice between them is more about the elementary school experience and the community feel than academic quality. Shawnee is known for its performing arts program, while Cherokee is known for its strong athletics and academics.
Which Town Has Better Housing and Lots?
This is where Medford and Marlton diverge most significantly.
Medford: Known for larger lots, historic homes, and distinctive properties. The average lot size in Medford is significantly larger than in Marlton, and many homes sit on an acre or more. You will find historic village homes, mid-century homes on larger lots, equestrian estates, and the unique lakefront community of Medford Lakes. The housing stock is more diverse in character but less diverse in type (fewer townhomes and condos).
Marlton: Known for well-maintained mid-century homes, colonials, and ranches on standard suburban lots. Marlton also has a wider range of townhomes, condos, and active adult communities, making it more accessible for first-time buyers and downsizers. The housing stock is more uniform but offers more options at different price points.
Winner: Depends on your priorities. Medford wins for space, character, and land. Marlton wins for housing variety, affordability, and options for different life stages.
Which Town Has Better Downtown and Amenities?
This is another area where the two towns differ significantly.
Medford: Medford's historic downtown on Main Street is one of the most charming in Burlington County. Independent shops, art galleries, antique stores, and excellent restaurants give it a small-town feel. The Medford Arts and Music Festival is a highlight of the year. However, the downtown is smaller, and for major shopping trips, you will need to drive to Marlton, Mount Laurel, or Cherry Hill.
Marlton: Marlton is a retail and dining hub. The Route 73 corridor is packed with shopping plazas, restaurants, and services. The Promenade at Sagemore offers upscale shopping and dining. Marlton has more restaurants, more stores, and more conveniences within the town itself. You do not have to leave Marlton for much of anything.
Winner: Marlton for convenience and variety. Medford for charm and character. If you want walkable historic charm, Medford wins. If you want everything at your fingertips, Marlton wins.
Which Town Has a Better Commute?
Both towns offer manageable commutes to Philadelphia, but Marlton has a clear advantage.
Medford: The drive to Center City Philadelphia takes 30 to 40 minutes. PATCO stations are a 20-minute drive away. The NJ Transit Atlantic City Line station in Atco offers an alternative. Medford's eastern location means a longer drive to the city, but the trade-off is more space and a quieter setting.
Marlton: The drive to Center City Philadelphia takes 20 to 30 minutes. PATCO is accessible via the Woodcrest or Ashland stations, about 10 to 15 minutes away. Marlton's location along Route 73 provides excellent highway access. The commute is clearly shorter and more convenient from Marlton.
Winner: Marlton. The shorter commute and better highway access are significant advantages for daily commuters. For a detailed comparison of commute times, read our Living in Marlton guide.
Which Town Is Better for Outdoor Recreation?
Medford wins this category decisively.
Medford: Medford is a gateway to the Pine Barrens. Wharton State Forest, the Mullica River, and the Batsto Village historic area are all within minutes. The town has excellent parks, equestrian facilities, and Medford Lakes offers a private lake system. For outdoor enthusiasts, Medford is extraordinary.
Marlton: Marlton has good parks and recreation facilities, but they are more traditional suburban amenities. The town has sports fields, playgrounds, and walking trails, but it does not have the same access to large-scale natural areas as Medford. The Pine Barrens are a longer drive from Marlton.
Winner: Medford, decisively. If outdoor recreation is a priority, Medford is the clear choice.
Which Town Has a Better Community Feel?
Both towns have strong communities, but the character is different.
Medford: Medford has a distinct identity and a proud, engaged community. The historic downtown, the equestrian culture, and the Pine Barrens setting give Medford a unique character. It feels like a small town, not a suburb. The community is tightly knit, and residents are deeply invested in preserving the town's character.
Marlton: Marlton is a classic family suburb. The community is welcoming, active, and oriented around schools, sports, and shopping. It is a great place to raise a family, but it does not have the same distinctive identity as Medford. Marlton is more of a collection of neighborhoods than a single town with a defined center.
Winner: Depends on your preference. Medford for distinctive character and small-town feel. Marlton for classic suburban community with everything you need.
Which Town Should You Choose?
Choose Medford if: You value historic character, larger properties, access to nature, and a strong sense of community identity. You are willing to trade a longer commute and fewer conveniences for more space and a more distinctive lifestyle. You want equestrian properties, lakefront living, or a rural feel.
Choose Marlton if: You want a convenient, amenity-rich suburban lifestyle with excellent schools, abundant shopping and dining, a shorter commute, and more housing options at different price points. You prefer having everything you need within a short drive.
Both are excellent communities. The right choice is the one that fits your priorities. I would be happy to help you explore both and find the right fit.
Still Have Questions About Medford vs Marlton?
Is Medford or Marlton more affordable?
Marlton is generally more affordable, with a lower entry point for homes (mid-$300,000s vs mid-$400,000s) and slightly lower property taxes. However, Medford offers larger lots and more distinctive properties for the higher price. The right choice depends on what you value in a home.
Which town has better schools, Medford or Marlton?
Both towns have excellent schools. Medford feeds into Shawnee High School, while Marlton feeds into Cherokee High School. Both are consistently ranked among the top high schools in New Jersey. The elementary schools in both districts are highly regarded. The choice is more about the community feel than academic quality.
Is the commute better from Medford or Marlton?
Marlton has a better commute. The drive to Philadelphia takes 20-30 minutes from Marlton compared to 30-40 minutes from Medford. PATCO stations are also closer to Marlton. Medford's longer commute is the trade-off for more space and a quieter setting.
Which town has more shopping and dining?
Marlton has significantly more shopping and dining options, with the Route 73 corridor and the Promenade at Sagemore offering a wide variety of stores and restaurants. Medford has a charming historic downtown with independent shops and excellent restaurants, but for major shopping trips, you will need to drive to Marlton or Mount Laurel.
Which town is better for outdoor recreation?
Medford is the clear winner for outdoor recreation. The town is a gateway to the Pine Barrens, Wharton State Forest, and the Mullica River. Medford Lakes offers a private lake system. Marlton has good parks and recreation facilities but does not have the same access to large-scale natural areas.
Which town is better for first-time home buyers?
Marlton is generally better for first-time buyers, with a wider range of affordable options including townhomes, smaller ranches, and condos starting in the mid-$300,000s. Medford's entry point is higher, and the housing stock is more heavily weighted toward single-family homes on larger lots. First-time buyers with a higher budget who want more space may still prefer Medford.
Bob Millaway
Redfin Senior Agent · AI Certified Agent™ · 636+ homes sold across Burlington County. I know both Medford and Marlton inside and out. Let me help you compare them for your specific situation and find the right community for you.
Contact BobExplore More