A clear view of Downtown Columbus with classic colonial-style storefronts and an empty main street under a bright blue sky.

The Pros and Cons of Living in Columbus, New Jersey

Real Estate Trends| AI Certified Agent™| Real Estate

July 29, 2025•2 min read

Curious if Columbus, NJ is the right place to live—or sell? Let’s break it down with real insights.

I’m Robert Millaway, your local AI-Certified Agent with eXp Realty. Whether you're selling a home, downsizing, or relocating, knowing the true pros and cons of Columbus, New Jersey will help you make confident, informed decisions—and avoid guesswork.

✅ The Pros of Living in Columbus, NJ

1. Rural Charm with Modern Access

Columbus delivers a small-town, countryside feel while still being minutes from the NJ Turnpike, I-295, and Route 206. It’s the best of both worlds—peaceful living without sacrificing connection to Philly, Trenton, or North Jersey.

2. Home to the Columbus Farmers Market

If you love fresh produce, antiques, or flea market finds, the Columbus Farmers Market is a local treasure. It draws visitors from across South Jersey and adds a lot of character to the area.

3. Spacious Homes and Larger Lots

Unlike more urbanized towns, Columbus offers larger properties, yards, and custom-built homes. It’s a great place to live—or list—if you're marketing to buyers who value space, privacy, and rural views.

4. 55+ Communities and Retirement Living

Columbus is home to popular 55+ developments like Homestead at Mansfield, making it a destination for retirees who want community, amenities, and low-maintenance living. If you’re selling in one of these neighborhoods, you’re in a strong niche.

⚠️ The Cons to Consider

1. Limited Walkability and Amenities

Columbus is spread out and car-dependent. While shopping and dining are available nearby, you’ll need to hop in the car to get most errands done. That’s important for buyers coming from more walkable towns.

2. Low Inventory Can Mean Fewer Choices

While that’s a plus for sellers, buyers may feel limited during slower seasons. For sellers, this is your edge—especially with an AI-powered pricing and marketing strategy that puts your listing in front of the right audience.

3. Not Ideal for Everyone

Some buyers prefer more hustle and bustle. Columbus appeals to a specific lifestyle—quiet, space-driven, and laid-back. As your agent, I help position your home to reach buyers who are actively searching for that exact experience.

Ready to Sell in Columbus?

Let’s talk about how my A.I. Listing Advantage can help you maximize your sale—whether you’re in a farmhouse, 55+ community, or custom build. We’ll combine data-backed marketing, smart pricing, and personal service to deliver results.

📞 Call me at (856) 288-2752 to schedule your personalized home-selling strategy session.

Bold. Bonafide. Bald.

#AICertifiedAgent #AICertified #robertmillaway #bobtherealtor
#ColumbusNJ #SouthJerseyRealEstate #SellWithAI #HomeSellingTips #FarmhouseLiving #ColumbusHomes #NJRealtor

Bob Millaway

Robert Millaway is a trailblazing real estate professional and marketing expert, proudly recognized as one of the few AI-Certified agents in the industry. Combining cutting-edge technology with deep empathy and strategic insight, Robert offers unparalleled service to homeowners navigating complex real estate challenges. His certification in AI technology sets him apart, enabling him to provide innovative, data-driven solutions that address the unique needs of distressed homeowners, FSBO sellers, downsizers, and those grappling with expired listings. With a commitment to understanding his clients’ deepest fears, goals, and motivations, Robert transforms struggles into success stories. He leverages his AI expertise to craft personalized marketing strategies that maximize exposure and results, from dynamic social media campaigns to engaging Facebook ads for robertmillaway.com. Using advanced tools like GoHighLevel and HeyGen, Robert ensures clients benefit from cutting-edge insights and unparalleled market visibility. His creative flair, such as locally-themed content, captivates audiences while subtly highlighting his expertise. At 62, Robert’s wealth of life experience enhances his ability to empathize with clients facing significant life transitions. His passion for helping homeowners stems from a deep understanding of their emotional and practical needs. Whether guiding clients through foreclosure fears, empowering FSBO sellers to succeed, or supporting downsizers in their next chapter, Robert’s AI certification allows him to deliver results with precision, efficiency, and care. As a forward-thinking innovator, Robert is committed to redefining real estate with technology and heart. From building exclusive buyer networks to crafting tailored strategies for homeowners, he is dedicated to ensuring each client’s journey is smooth, confident, and rewarding. With a unique blend of expertise, creativity, and advanced AI tools, Robert Millaway is not just a real estate agent but a trusted partner in transforming challenges into opportunities.

Back to Blog