Philadelphia Eagles and Kansas City Chiefs players intensely competing for unusual pizzas at a Super Bowl party, with the Eagles grabbing a mini M&M pizza and the Chiefs reaching for a mustard-based pizza

πŸˆπŸ• Super Bowl Showstoppers: 5 Most Unusual & Tasty Pizzas for Your Party! πŸ•πŸ†

February 06, 2025β€’2 min read

The Super Bowl is all about epic plays, unforgettable commercials, and of courseβ€”insanely good food! πŸ—πŸΊ While wings and chips are classics, why not bring the heat this year with some of the wildest, most unique pizzas in South Jersey? πŸ”₯ These pies will have your guests talking long after the final touchdown! πŸ†


1️⃣ M & M Pizza – Lou's Deli (Delanco, NJ) πŸ«πŸ•

πŸ† Perfect for: The Sweet & Salty Snacker

Why settle for just dessert when you can combine it with pizza? 🀯 Lou's Deli takes game day snacking to the next level with their M&M-topped pizzaβ€”a bizarre but surprisingly delicious blend of melted cheese, warm chocolate, and crispy crust. This one is sure to be the MVP of your party!

πŸ“ 309 Burlington Ave, Delanco, NJ
πŸ“ž (856) 461-2570
🌍 Yelp Page


2️⃣ The Jewish Cowboy – Tony Boloney’s (Atlantic City, NJ) πŸ„πŸ”₯

πŸ† Perfect for: The BBQ-Loving Brisket Fan

You want big game flavors? This pizza is bringing the blitz! πŸ’₯ 8-hour smoked brisket, horseradish, Passover sauce, and gooey cheese combine for a pizza that's as bold as a fourth-quarter Hail Mary. 🏈

πŸ“ 300 Oriental Ave, Atlantic City, NJ
πŸ“ž (609) 344-8669
🌍 www.tonyboloneys.com


3️⃣ Mustard Pie – Papa’s Tomato Pies (Robbinsville, NJ) πŸŒ­πŸ•

πŸ† Perfect for: The Tailgate Traditionalist

Is it a pizza? Is it a hot dog? It’s BOTH. πŸ† Instead of tomato sauce, Papa’s uses spicy brown mustard as the base, layering it with cheese and toppings. If your crew loves stadium-style eats, this mustard pie will be a total crowd-pleaser.

πŸ“ 19 Robbinsville Allentown Rd, Robbinsville, NJ
πŸ“ž (609) 208-0006
🌍 www.papastomatopies.com


4️⃣ Honey Glazed Chicken Cutlet Pizza – Carluccio’s Coal Fired Pizza (Northfield, NJ) πŸ―πŸ”

πŸ† Perfect for: The Wing Lover Who Can’t Decide

Can’t choose between wings or pizza? This pie delivers the best of both worlds! πŸ—πŸ”₯ Honey-glazed chicken cutlets tossed in homemade buffalo sauce, caramelized onions, mozzarella, and blue cheese dressing come together in a coal-fired crust masterpiece.

πŸ“ 1200 New Rd #102, Northfield, NJ
πŸ“ž (609) 677-0470
🌍 www.carluccioscoalfiredpizza.com


5️⃣ Italian Hot Dog Pizza – The Brothers Restaurant (Red Bank, NJ) πŸŒ­πŸ§€

πŸ† Perfect for: The Ultimate Jersey Guy/Girl

It’s halftime. You’re hungry. You need a power play meal. Enter: The Italian Hot Dog Pizza! 🏈 This beauty is loaded with sliced hotdogs, sautΓ©ed peppers, onions, and crispy potatoesβ€”it’s like a tailgate on a crust! πŸš—πŸ’¨

πŸ“ 188 W Front St, Red Bank, NJ
πŸ“ž (732) 530-3356
🌍 www.brothersredbank.com


πŸ† Final Play: Which Pizza Are You Bringing?

This Super Bowl Sunday, forget the same old delivery order. Bring one of these legendary pizzas to the party, and you’ll be the real MVP. πŸ†πŸ• Whether you're going for sweet, smoky, spicy, or outrageous, these pies are guaranteed to be a touchdown with your guests!

πŸ‘‡ Which one are you picking? Drop your favorite in the comments! πŸˆπŸ•πŸ”₯

Robert Millaway is South Jersey’s leading AI Realtor and a certified A.I. Agent helping homeowners sell faster, smarter, and with more clarity. Recognized as a South Jersey Home Selling Expert, he blends advanced technology with proven real estate strategy to guide buyers and sellers across Burlington and Camden County.

By combining data-driven pricing, AI-powered marketing, and hyperlocal South Jersey insight, Robert creates a selling experience that delivers better exposure, stronger negotiation power, and results that outperform traditional methods. Whether you’re preparing to sell, exploring your buying options, or need a strategic edge in today’s market, Robert provides clear guidance and modern solutions built around your goals.

Your next move deserves an expert who understands South Jersey, understands people, and understands the power of AI.

Bob Millaway

Robert Millaway is South Jersey’s leading AI Realtor and a certified A.I. Agent helping homeowners sell faster, smarter, and with more clarity. Recognized as a South Jersey Home Selling Expert, he blends advanced technology with proven real estate strategy to guide buyers and sellers across Burlington and Camden County. By combining data-driven pricing, AI-powered marketing, and hyperlocal South Jersey insight, Robert creates a selling experience that delivers better exposure, stronger negotiation power, and results that outperform traditional methods. Whether you’re preparing to sell, exploring your buying options, or need a strategic edge in today’s market, Robert provides clear guidance and modern solutions built around your goals. Your next move deserves an expert who understands South Jersey, understands people, and understands the power of AI.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog